Cape Coral and Fort Myers offer an incredible mix of delicious food, waterfront dining, and fun Florida vibes. Whether you’re looking for authentic Mexican cuisine, classic Italian dishes, fresh seafood, or a romantic dinner with a view, this guide highlights the best restaurants for guests staying at Villa Melusina.
1. Monarca’s Mexican Restaurant (Cape Coral)
Cuisine: Mexican & Tex-Mex
Perfect for: Families, groups, margarita lovers
A lively, colorful restaurant serving authentic Mexican dishes with big portions and great service. One of Cape Coral’s favorites.
Don’t miss:
- Fajitas (steak, chicken, shrimp, or mixed)
- Tableside fresh guacamole
- Carnitas platter
- Frozen margaritas
Fun, flavorful, and always welcoming.
2. Papa Joe’s Italian Restaurant (Cape Coral)
Cuisine: Italian, Pizza, Homemade Pasta
Perfect for: Families, classic Italian meals, big portions
Papa Joe’s is a beloved staple in Cape Coral, known for its homemade sauces, traditional recipes, and warm, old-school Italian atmosphere.
Try:
- Chicken Parmesan
- Papa Joe’s Special Pizza
- Baked Ziti
- Homemade Meatballs
Comfort food at its best — hearty, authentic, and satisfying.
3. FINS Seafood & Dive Bar (Cape Coral)
Cuisine: Fresh seafood, casual coastal
Perfect for: Relaxed nights, seafood lovers
Fresh fish, fun cocktails, and friendly service.
Favorites:
- Blackened Mahi Tacos
- Seafood Combo Platter
- Key Lime Pie
4. The Boathouse Tiki Bar & Grill (Cape Coral)
Cuisine: Waterfront American / Seafood
Perfect for: Sunset views, cocktails, live music
One of the best waterfront dining spots in the region.
Don’t miss:
- Coconut Shrimp
- Gulf Grouper Sandwich
- Rum Runner cocktails
5. Gusto Cucina Italiana (Cape Coral)
Cuisine: Authentic Italian
Perfect for: Romantic dinners, homemade pasta lovers
Family-run and cozy, with a menu full of classics.
Best dishes:
- Lasagna
- Veal Saltimbocca
- Tiramisu
6. Cape Coral Fish House (Cape Coral)
Cuisine: Seafood
Perfect for: Great value, fresh fish, local vibe
A local favorite for simple, high-quality seafood.
Try:
- Crab-Stuffed Flounder
- Ahi Tuna
- Scallops
7. Doc Ford’s Rum Bar & Grille (Fort Myers)
Cuisine: Caribbean-inspired seafood
Perfect for: Island vibes, families, lunches by the water
Top picks:
- Yucatan Shrimp
- Conch Chowder
- Fish Tacos
8. Fresh Kitchen (Fort Myers)
Cuisine: Healthy, build-your-own bowls
Perfect for: Quick, clean eating
Try:
- Spicy Thai Coconut Bowl
- BBQ Chicken Bowl
- Sweet Potato Noodles
9. Blu Sushi (Fort Myers)
Cuisine: Sushi & Asian Fusion
Perfect for: Sushi nights, trendy atmosphere
Must-try:
- Volcano Roll
- Black Widow Roll
- Tuna Tataki
10. The Veranda (Downtown Fort Myers)
Cuisine: Southern fine dining
Perfect for: Special occasions, romantic dinners
Historic, elegant, and charming.
Recommended:
- Almond-Crusted Grouper
- Southern Fried Chicken
- Bread Pudding